tmo logo
throwingmusic
 
home
media
shop
tourdates
dot
blog
dot
mailing list
 
 

24 January 2008

Are You Sure You Can Sell This?


My latest song from "Speedbath" is here. It's called "Around Dusk" and I hope it treats you well.

Now that CASH is a viable entity and not just an amorphous blob floating around in our heads, those of us who work here are becoming increasingly aware of its quieter gifts. I knew this construct was necessary in order for us all to share interesting music, but intangibles like political implications are now sneaking into my world view.

I've always believed that what I do has more in common with the field of research than the field of entertainment. Of course, from the beginning, I knew that in order to reach people with sound, I had to make records and play clubs. Sounds simple, gets ugly.

In order for someone like me, (The Artist) to reach out and grab the Music Business Experts who in turn, reach out and grab someone like you (The Audience), they ask you in not-so-subtle ways to play by the "rules" of the entertainment industry.

These rules are not mysterious, nor are they difficult to follow. In fact, there's only one real rule: be attractive. If you work in the recording industry, you must play attractive music, you must be an attractive human. If you work in the film industry, you must make attractive movies, you must be an attractive human, etc.

The definition of attractive is where we all fall down. Healthy people view it as a melange of sensory, intellectual and emotional input. Healthy people are attracted to music and film -- and humans -- that move us.

The wildly unhealthy entertainment industry views attraction as: easy. That's it. Just like high school! This is how bimbos happen and I don't just mean the Barbie doll kind. Male bimbos, female bimbos, musical and filmic bimbos...a bimbo is anything one-dimensional enough to be taken at face value with no potential for insight or growth on the part of the consumer (oooh...scary...insight!)

Every time Nothing is wrapped in Fashion and sold to the Public, a bimbo is born. Bimbos always make someone money. They're e-e-e-e-easy.

I've watched musicians I loved buy into this insidious phenomenon. The idea that to bring their music to more people they'd need to dumb it down. Whether they believed in their own success or their own failure didn't matter, the end result was the same: something imaginary killed their art.

The "experts" ask, are you a bimbo? If your answer is no, then you flunk the music business and eventually you disappear. If your answer is well...I could be...here's a picture of me 'looking cool'...here's a flimsy song... then you're allowed to share your music with the public. But what music? You dumbed it down! Why bother? For twenty years I lived with this quandary.

Thank you, CASH people, for removing me from that ugly world, for taking our amorphous blob and running with it. I make records, I play clubs, I'm in the music business, but I no longer have to answer to some vague idea of a "market" or demographic. I no longer have to play by the crap rules of the entertainment industry, I only have to answer to my stake-holders.

Now my job is to throw myself, body and soul, into my research and share it with you.

Love,
Kristin


Note: As of this writing, Kristin's CASH subscribers come from 12 different countries on 5 different continents.

"Are You Shore You Can Sell This?" - Illustration by Wyatt True O'Connell (at age 3)

25 Comments:

Blogger Matt Hannan said...

You are most welcome and THANK YOU!!!
G'luck with the research.

10:47 PM  
Blogger Divinyl said...

Kristin, we love you because we love your music. We want you to make the music you want to be making! That's what we want to hear. You are right, the industry is often more about packaging, sadly, than anything else...but talent has a way of winning through. You are attractive, because your songs speak to us (although I sound a bit overemotional in saying that!). If I like music, I couldn't give two hoots what the person making it looks like. This is not any comment on how you actually do look, it's just I agree that it shouldn't matter.

You have a lot of us behind you here...and I, for one, feel very priveliged to have been invited along for the ride! x

10:57 PM  
Blogger Thor said...

Kristin,

Just got done listening to the new song and I have to say I'm liking the
'new mood clothes'... in a way "Around Dusk" feels unlike anything else I've heard you do -- I've noticed you've 'worked the atmosphere' lately -- awesome!! :)

Is there any way we could still get full-quality mix stems? In FLAC maybe? Was there a problem with this option?

...and the way you're doing this whole CASH thing, I'll be along for the ride for an indefinite period ;) You're excited, so am I. As Matt said, you're most welcome and THANK YOU :)

6:04 PM  
Blogger Thor said...

oh - this song is treating me especially well btw, just thought i'd let you know ;)

6:06 PM  
Blogger Chucky said...

Hi Gang,

I've gone way out on a limb and really re-worked Around Dusk.

I was inspired by the dark sound of the bass and piano, so I took just some of the instruments and threw in some (public domain) comments from a certain president.

I hope I'm not offending anyone with the result. I imagine some fans might be put off by me tossing Dubya into the elements of a Kristin Hersh song and changing the meaning of the song completely. But as soon as I heard the music in this song, it prompted me to think of it as a lament for what has happened on the world stage.

Sometimes, sadness speaks louder than anger.

6:30 PM  
Blogger shannon said...

kristin, i have been such a HUGE fan of yours for many years, and i cannot believe that i am finally commenting here. your music makes my life richer than it would be without knowing it, and i thank you so much. (COME TO DALLAS!!)

first of all, around dusk is crazy beautiful, and i agree with thor - a different sound from you. thanks for always surprising.

secondly, and this may suck, but i'd like to know more about what YOU have experienced in the big bad record biz. i completely see what you say, of course. there's a lot of shit out there that conforms to a formula. but there is also a lot of great music being released by people that i respect tremendously.

what are your thoughts on the way radioheaad tried to release their latest and the results?

it seems like an exciting time of change for us, the audience, and you artists both.

we can remake the mold, maybe?

9:39 PM  
Blogger Kristin said...

Hi All,

Thank you for the good listening -- I've been thinking lately what a giving and generous act that is. I'm really grateful. Your thoughtful comments are also appreciated.

Divinyl...I know what you mean. Thanks!

Thor...we'll try and get the WAVs up in the next couple of days. Billy says, it was his fault that we neglected to do so.

Chucky...this is what it's all about. Do what you hear. Each time you do, the -RW project is a success. Thank you for that.

Shannon...I'm not sure how many specifics I could share in a public forum without getting into trouble. In my experience, telling the truth doesn't count for much in court.

I usually refrain from commenting specifically on my peers because I don't think it's my place. I think the Radiohead strategy was a great success, that they got way more credit for innovation than even they'd be comfortable with (even 50FootWave had done it 2 years before) and beyond that I have no standing to comment. What they do with their business is just that, their business. I'm sure you understand.

There's a TON of good music out there and there always has been. It's just that now, it's way easier for it to find listeners.

Hopefully, someday I'll find myself in Dallas, you'll find me and we can chat!

Love,
Kristin

9:24 AM  
Blogger thome said...

"Nothing is wrapped in Fashion and sold to the Public"

That's a beautifully concise definition of so much that passes for "entertainment" these days. Or "creativity". or "art".

Having recently quit my desk-jockey job in an attempt to rescue my soul (or something) and begin to imagine contributing something creative, or useful, or interesting, I am beyond delighted that you seem to have liberated yourself from the constraints & compromises of the industry. In my current situation I can make no financial contribution to the project without depriving myself of food, but I guess the beauty part is that me & my CASH-strapped kind can also come along for the ride, wherever it takes us...

7:15 PM  
Blogger Thor said...

Done and posted a short reversion of the track -- I don't know what else to say except this is what I heard in response to a few plays of the track - I also like to play around with stereo, as I did on the reversion.

This one really is for me ripe for re-mixing. Real good pieces here for many puzzles to be made, K. ;)

---Thor

5:39 PM  
Blogger Kristin said...

I just had to say that I'm really enjoying this round of remixes. Thank you all.

Love,
K

7:57 PM  
Blogger Chucky said...

This round is starting out really well.
Everyone is taking something very different from the original.
Thor, I'm enthralled by your swooshy electronics. I don't even know how they were achieved. Sounds great...like some Amnesiac-era tune by Radiohead.

8:56 PM  
Blogger gurdonark said...

Well put.

Rock failed of its initial promise because of this limitation--to succeed, one had to be either a beauty (in all of the various literal or metaphorical ways) or a glittering crowd-pleasing substitute for beauty (whether ´bard for a generation' or a 'boss' or even a ´thin white duke').

The resulting commodification of the artist in search of sufficient sales to justify the funds expended to create such a bright and glittering quetzal bird created that dangerous distance, where idol worship, alienation and even (metaphorically, but sadly, sometimes literally) mark david chapman lurk.

This new culture offers the promise of a different way. The technological and structural barriers between the artist and the audience dissolve in the best ways. It no longer matters if the artist is an object of desire, a style-maker or a fashion forward pace-setter. What matters is that the artist makes a kind of music that the particular set of listeners love to hear.

The irony is that the record company arrangements had become so skewed away from the artist, at a time when these technological advances in product creation and marketing should have skewed towards the artist, that a cadre of small-business artists can yet arise who use this new freedom to make money recording and releasing.

I don´t read the 'beautiful' part of your post as a request for affirmation about individuals, so please forgive me if I do not engage in the customary reassuring critique and description of the innards and outwards of beauty.

I´ll instead use a metaphor about CASH drawing on a topic on my mind lately. I just came out yesterday from several days on a vacation in the Costa Rican rainforest. Costa Rica enchants me because it abolished its military in 1948 and invested the funds saved in education and health care. The result is not a rich country materially, but a country which has suffered far less from poverty than the models used by their neighbors.

In Costa, tourism has become one of their main two industries. But they realize that the biological diversity which draws visitors will be lost if development occurs in a stereotypic ways. They instead must build a network of eco-lodges and ways to integrate the tourism into the local culture and economy.

This is not only a macro process but a micro process--in remote Drake´s Bay, where we stayed, each lodge seeks to raise funds to help ensure not only preservation of the jungle but also education of the local kids, so that everyone can share in this process. They seek to avoid the spectre of massive resorts and rampant change.

It seems to me in music that the jungle, aided by the new technology, is slowly covering over the resort hotels of the traditional recording industry. No longer will limousines drive a select and beautiful few to the luxury suite of the resort.

The jungle offers artists a simple choice--merge with it or cease to exist. The individual artist can be a scarlet macaw, setting out colors for those interested to see, or a howler monkey, emitting warnings for all to hear. Nobody promises that the audience will necessarily support the artist--even in this metaphoric way, it´s still a jungle out there. But in this new world, it´s a jungle in which the artist is part of the ecology, and not just a gliterring face of those who knock down trees and put in hotels.

I will buy the new song once I return to the US this weekend.

Greetings from Heredia, Costa Rica, where the skies are full of bright and colorful new song, by birds of greater and lesser plumage, singing because it is what birds do, and not because of how they are caged.

2:51 AM  
Blogger bryan said...

Beautifull song.Really looking forward to your show in London.

5:53 PM  
Blogger Kristin said...

gurdonark...What a wonderful and thoughtful piece of writing. Thank you for that. I think the music business is on the right track...as opposed to the recording industry -- that's been broken for a long time. Thanks also for the support!

bryan...thanks for coming to the London show...be sure to say hi.

9:30 PM  
Blogger Ellie G said...

Hi Kristin, I just wanted to say that at the moment what you're doing, and saying in these blog posts, is an absolute inspiration. Especially for someone who is looking forward to spending more time to work on her own research! Thank you so much for all the work and being out there :)

xx

p.s. also, thanks to CASH for turning me onto Xiu Xiu :)

6:37 AM  
Blogger PeteZ said...

This new song does treat me well. ^.^
I like your "Bimbo" reasearch Kristin. lol.
You really do play from the soul. I have the same Promies in my own comic art.
"Play from your F@$%ing Soul."—Bill Hicks
I agree. Real beuty and art is not found in a makeup case, but in the feelings, and learning.

A person that jiggles car keys can be entertaining, so they technicly are an entertainer...but not an artist. Is it saying any thing? Are we learning any thing? I enjoy your music Kristin because of the interesting moods you display, and the new perspectives I hear. I love seeing from new perspectives. Thats why I love story telling.

Depends who you ask when dissecting what art is(so much fun to ask). I think music should say something. That something in its own voice. The Art voice is not for every one to hear with imbrace. One size fits all music speaks loudly sometimes. "Speaking loudly, saying nothing. You're confusing me." [Theives in the Night—Mos Def]

Just an observation. Your songs no matter the band, have felt very honest. The first song I heard by you was from Muses, Buzz. My reaction was, wow this girl is very honest, grounded, and been through some sh¡t. haha

Have a good weekend every body, looking forward to doing a rendition of Around Dusk.
peteZ

ps Never heard a pop beat with you before( not sure the right name for the type of drum beat). You did the pop beat with style! :)
Didnt feel easy ;)

7:21 PM  
Blogger Matt Moran said...

I got my window sticker yesterday! *squee*
It's now adorning my car's back window.

Re: Fashion/Marketing - I've been reading Oliver James' "Affluenza" recently, & seeing common themes with Guy Debord's "La Societe du Spectacle". Worth reading both, though the issues raised are too complex to go into here. Naomi Klein's "No Logo"'s another good 'un - it's interesting to see how many writers are making the same conclusion.

6:14 AM  
Blogger anne said...

Just to play devil's advocate...would an artist be able to work bimbo-free if s/he hadn't already hoed herself for twenty years through the man? I think collaboration is a great thing, and I speak frequently of what a "CASH" community environment means in the record industry. Does it work if you haven't put in all the sweat of years of working for the man? I doubt I could get much in the way of a donation online if I weren't already known. So then how doe's one become known?

I have all my plans and ideas of how that might be possible, I just felt like sharing the thought. Luckily I have an okay job and the means to burn a bunch of my own music to give away for free in order to promote myself (just to get someone to listen) that way, but when yr so busy working the day job, when do you get to perform. Christ, is that a conundrum?

ACR, aka: Crystal Shit

9:28 PM  
Blogger Divinyl said...

Anne,

As good a way as any to start getting heard is to be talked about on music blogs. I run one, so if you want to send me one of said CDs to check out, that would be a pleasure :o) You can find my e-mail address, if you want to get in touch, by clicking my name here and then clicking my blog name when that takes you to my profile.#

You might also want to consider getting in touch with Tom Robinson over at BBC Radio 6...he has a show where he plays only new and unsigned artists...great exposure.

D.x

5:07 AM  
Blogger Matt Moran said...

Absolutely do-able, BUT it's obviously going to be hard work since you're not using that vast pre-made infrastructure of marketing & palm-greasing for airplay. As Divinyl says, get mentions on music blogs, but also, do live gigs, get a hardcore following of fans, distribute free mp3s so you build stats on last.fm & get your fans to request you be available on iTunes.

A mate of mine's doing just this, mainly through the live gig route but also by MySpace & her band's website where they've long given away freebie mp3s (not CC'ed but hey), & now she's got her first album out (see http://www.theadenoids.co.uk). Another friend does loads & loads of solo gigs in Second Life. She's known there as Cylindrian Rutabaga, Grace Buford in RL. She doesn't give away freebie mp3s BUT she plays literally almost every night in Second Life & has the obligatory MySpace & separate web page. She'll even do you custom versions of har album if there's a track you really want that's not on it, & there's room on the disc. :-)

6:48 AM  
Blogger swine said...

Kristin, between you and Elliot Smith you have inspired me more than any other artists alive or dead on the planet. Since the Muses i've listened to you grow, and struggle.
thanks for the peek inside,
i really hope the Cash initiative works, it sounds interesting and, in a perfect, ungreedy uncorporate world, all music would be given the same amount of attention and reward.
i will support as far as i can and promote it to all i know.
thanks again for all the fantastic music.
xx

10:07 AM  
Blogger PeteZ said...

Weekly Updates, and free downloadables seams to be effective for creating interest. Because of the updates and blog I check this site often. (And because Kristen charming)

The site, Home Star Runner, skiped the mass marketing altogether and have made thier site their full time jobs. They did it through clean design and weekly updates. Every Monday there was a new cartoon. I started watching them in college, and 6 years later I'm still checking their updates.

This Home Star Runner site was created by 2 guys originally on Mario Paint! They have DVDs of their cartoons to sell and I hear they are doing pretty well, and most importantly, they are owned by them selves.

SO weekly updates + persistance + internet = your goals :)

3:06 PM  
Blogger Kristin said...

Anne...I suppose I'm going to have to echo what the others here have said. It's possible, the Internet certainly make it easier -- though much of what was available to me and my band 'back in the day' is just gone now, things like a thriving college radio panel for instance.

Throwing Muses only ever got signed because we sent out 1000 cassettes and bugged enough college stations here in the U.S. to play our stuff that we ended up having a 'hit' first. That alone was a full time job. We also played on every bill that would have us...as many gigs per week as we could convince bookers to put us on, usually for no money.

4AD would have never heard of us without all that work and expense.

Music blogs, weekly (or at least regular updates) and a hell of a lot of stubbornness will get you pretty far. If it's worth it to you and you can't live without doing it -- something will usually work out.

Good luck!

5:17 PM  
Blogger marcf29 said...

I do agree with divinyl, if there arez people looking fr your music then you'll exist for us at least.
I'm not in the "van gogh's syndrom", no need of being an "artiste maudit". But the problem is that the music industry is creating those "artistes maudits", for a britney or a madonna how many are forced to be heard by a few persons. In France a famous record company director has said that if the new Edith Piaf or Jacques Brel would appear at his desk he'd never sign them cause they wouldn't sold anything nowadays. Music is now a buisness and certainly not connected with art anymore.
I just hope that you will continue to share your music with us, maybe the world doesn't need it, but i need it.
I hope that you'll excuse my awful english, as I am a little froggy

7:30 AM  
Blogger Laurent said...

Hi Kristin,
A quick note to thank you for this song. It is so addictive that I found myself playing it again and again a whole night's work long.
I missed your last play here in France and am looking forward to see you playing again.
And now I have the opportunity, I'd like to say thanks for your music. Your records are one of the very few that still continues to amaze me even 20 year, for some,after listening to them for the first time.
Love from France
Laurent

btw : would you share the fingerpicking tab for "arounddusk" ?

9:32 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home